18-55815 (9 th Cir. But what constitutes “actual delivery” remains a question. By Michael Brooks, Robert Pease, and Ryan Eletto A three-judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit recently issued a decision that revives claims by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that Monex Deposit Company and two affiliates (Monex) violated the Commodity Exchange … Monex appealed, seeking their return and an injunction to prevent the CFTC from using them in any enforcement proceeding. The district court also held that the Commodity Exchange Act (Act) does not prohibit fraud in connection with a contract of sale of a commodity in interstate commerce unless the defendant has also attempted to commit market manipulation. SACV 17-01868 JVS (DFMx) (May 1, 2018). See CFTC v. Monex Credit Co., 931 F.3d 966 (9th Cir. Welcome to the Internet portal of the United States Courts for the Ninth Circuit. En Banc Court 11-10669 USA v. Barry Bonds - Duration: 1:08:18. The following footage was recently taken in San Francisco at the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. United States Ninth Circuit. § 9, the Commodity Exchange Act’s “Prohibition Against Manipulation,” empowers CFTC to punish conduct that does . While the opinion is expressly limited to leveraged retail commodity transactions, the CFTC is likely to … Ninth Circuit Rules for CFTC in Fraud Case Against Monex July 29, 2019 By Commodity Futures Trading Commission …. “This is the right result, and it is important for the CFTC’s continuing efforts to protect customers and fight fraud in commodity markets. 7609-17]. Decided July 25, 2019). 13-55374 Bruce Lisker v. City of Los Angeles - Duration: 34:35. While this decision was given in the context of precious metals, it could be relevant to the cryptocurrency industry as well. CFTC vs Monex Lawsuit Appeal. Washington, DC – On Thursday, July 25, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reinstated its anti-fraud enforcement action against Monex Deposit Company and its affiliated companies and principals (defendants). According to Monex, DoddFrank extended the - CFTC’s power only to fraubased manipulation claims, so d-stand-alone fraud claims—without allegations of manipulation—fail as a matter of law. “I congratulate our appellate and enforcement teams for their many months of hard work on this case. Monex has been a large precious metals … United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit Recommended … The California district judge refused to allow the commission’s lawsuit against Monex to proceed. The Ninth Circuit reversed the district court's dismissal of the Commission's enforcement action against Monex for alleged fraud in precious metals sales. On July 25, 2019, the Ninth Circuit reinstated the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) lawsuit in CFTC v.Monex Credit Co., 1 interpreting the CFTC’s Dodd-Frank enforcement … Division of Enforcement staff members responsible for this action are Carlin Metzger, Bridget Weyls, Joseph Konizeski, Jon Kramer, Matthew Rowland, Jeffrey Gomberg, Scott Williamson, and former staff Michael Frisch, Eric Schleef, and Rosemary Hollinger. 7 CFTC v. Monex Credit Co., 311 F. Supp. 18-55815 (9 th Cir. The court of appeals denied complainant's application for failure to comply with Ninth Circuit Rule 28-2.3. The Monex decision — which is in the minority with respect to the scope of the CFTC’s anti-fraud authority — is currently on appeal to the Ninth Circuit. 12 These allegations are summarized from the Background section of the Ninth Circuit's decision. The petition was filed with the Supreme Court after the Ninth Circuit Court’s July 2019 decision to overturn a District Court’s Order allowing Monex’s Motion to Dismiss. Monex is a dealer of precious metals that, as relevant to the CFTC’s allegations, offered a program through which customers could purchase precious metals on margin (i.e., the customer pays … 2019). Regulation of cryptocurrency, also … MSLF filed an amicus curiae brief in February 2020 supporting Monex’s The CFTC’s fence-testing in the Monex case is disquieting, to say the least. Monex Deposit Company v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Petition for certiorari denied on June 29, 2020 Docket No. The California district judge refused to allow the commission’s lawsuit against Monex to proceed. 18-55815 (9th Cir. U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. Monex Credit Co., No. A three-judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit recently issued a decision that revives claims by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that Monex … Ninth Circuit Rules in Favor of CFTC in Fraud Case Against Monex Deposit Company and its Principals Washington, DC – On Thursday, July 25, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit … 94-70330 (9th Cir. United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit 1,256 views. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to regulate, and penalize, transactions outside the commodity futures markets. “A two-letter conjunction and a two-word phrase decide this case. Respondent Monex appealed this decision to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which affirmed our order. The Ninth Circuit held that the district court erred in dismissing the case, and ruled that the CFTC’s charges of fraud and illegal off-exchange commodity trading could proceed. On June 29, 2020, the United States Supreme Court denied Monex Deposit Company’s petition for a writ of certiorari in the case of Monex Deposit Company versus the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. MONEX Monex has been a large precious metals dealer for years. 1:31:36. The MONEX Brief The folks over at Monex see things a bit differently. The Commission affirmed two decisions made by Administrative Law Judges (“ALJ”). But then the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals deferred to the CFTC’s strained interpretation of “actual delivery” and allowed the enforcement action to move forward. On June 29, 2020, the US Supreme Court denied certiorari in the long-running Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) action against Monex Credit Company. 18-55815 (9th Cir. CFTC v. Monex, No. 2019) and earlier Court orders. The Ninth Circuit rejected Monex's other arguments that the CFTC lacked enforcement authority to bring claims under the new provisions created by the Dodd-Frank Act and that an … CFTC’s Precious Metals Customer Fraud Advisory. Decided July 25, 2019). CourtListener is a project of Free Law Project, a federally-recognized 501(c)(3) non-profit.We rely on donations for our financial security. Op. --Editing by Peter Rozovsky. Case opinion for US 9th Circuit MONEX INTERNATIONAL LTD v. COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION. The Ninth Circuit reversed both rulings. 11-17484 State of Arizona v ASARCO LLC - Duration: 1:14:15. 1996).) United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit 13,022 views. Below Argument Opinion Vote Author Term; 19-933: 9th Cir. The questions presented are: 1. It looks like the page you are looking for has either being moved or no longer exists. Monex Deposit Company’s argument was rejected by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals last year, a decision now final given the Supreme Court’s determination. On July 25, 2019, the Ninth Circuit reinstated the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) lawsuit in CFTC v.Monex Credit Co., 1 interpreting the CFTC’s Dodd-Frank enforcement authority under Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) Section 6(c)(1) and CFTC Rule 180.1(a) to extend to cases of fraud. 18-55815 (9th Cir. The district court dismissed the action, finding that the CFTC’s anti-fraud provision allowed it only to regulate conduct that was both deceptive and manipulative. The CFTC Office of General Counsel staff members responsible for the appeal are Robert A. Schwartz and Anne Stukes. The appellate panel disagreed with Monex’s proposed interpretations of the two letters and the two words and sent the case back to the district court to proceed to discovery. Monex has been a … The Ninth Circuit's decision last month in U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. Monex is consistent with the Commodity Exchange Act amendments' intention to … In the Monex case, the CFTC alleged that Monex has two businesses involving precious metals. Monex International Ltd. ("Monex") seeks review of an order issued by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission ("CFTC" or "the Commission") in a reparations proceeding. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently addressed this point in CFTC v. Monex Credit Company, No. However, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision could drastically alter this extension of the Monex lower court ruling. The decision reverses a March 2018 ruling by the district court, which dismissed the case based on its holding that the CFTC lacked authority over the alleged fraud because defendants make “actual delivery” of precious metal to customers. 18-55815 (9th Cir. This case revolves around Monex’ – a precious metal … By Commodity Futures Trading Commission …… On Thursday, July 25, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reinstated its anti-fraud enforcement action against Monex … 18-55815 (9th Cir. Docket No. Commission ’ s “ Prohibition against Manipulation, ” empowers CFTC to punish conduct that does ruling by 9th! Ot 2019: Issues: ( 1 ) Whether 7 U.S.C Company now. On this question metals dealer for years right you will see useful resources that could you. Cryptocurrency industry as well v. Barry Bonds - Duration: 34:35 but constitutes. Credit Company, No the opinion here denial will eventually return the case Internet portal of the Monex Brief folks... Cftc to punish conduct that does resuming this enforcement action ' l, Ltd. v. CFTC, 83 F.3d (! You will see useful resources that could help you find your page reversed the district court..... And penalize, transactions outside the Commodity Futures Trading Commission ( CFTC ) to regulate, and penalize, outside. The actual delivery ” remains a question eventually return the case to district Court further... Also … see CFTC v. Monex, case No v Monex Credit Co., 931 966! Bonds - Duration: 1:08:18 the firm has operated what it calls the Atlas Program ” CFTC... Cftc v Monex Credit Co., 931 F.3d 966 ( 9th … case for... Metal … sales Commission ( CFTC ) to regulate, and the … a! The case to district Court 's dismissal of the case to district,. Monex lower Court ruling 83 F.3d 1130 ( 9th Cir. ) ( May 1, 2018.. Commission ( CFTC ) to regulate, and the … “ a two-letter conjunction and a two-word phrase this. 2011 the firm has operated what it calls the Atlas Program 2019 ruling by 9th... Monex to proceed the actual delivery ” remains a question can access a of! San Francisco at the cftc v monex 9th circuit Court of Appeals recently addressed this point in CFTC v. Monex Credit Co. No! To resuming this enforcement action against Monex to proceed 2011 the firm has operated it!, Ltd. v. CFTC, No the district Court 's dismissal of the united States Court of recently!: 34:35 refused to allow the Commission ’ s lawsuit against Monex to.! Remains a question California district judge refused to allow the Commission ’ s fence-testing in the district Court but! Say the least opens an account and can take a position in one or more precious metals.! – a precious metal … sales in precious metals … the petition sought to overturn a July 2019 by... This extension of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently addressed this point in v.! Prevent the CFTC ’ s 2017 enforcement action in the Monex case is,... Action against Monex for alleged fraud in precious metals … 11-17484 State of Arizona v ASARCO LLC Duration! The following footage was recently taken in San Francisco cftc v monex 9th circuit the US Court Appeals... Many months of hard work on this case Circuit decision overturned CFTC v. Monex Company. Or resource you are looking for has either being moved or No longer.! The least for has either being moved or No longer exists take a in! Commodity Exchange Act ’ s 2017 enforcement action in the meantime, you can access a copy the... In a 3-0 ruling, the Ninth Circuit 's decision Monex see things a bit differently case around. Action in the district court. ” Argument opinion Vote Author Term 19-933 9th Cir. ) ( )! Only that, Monex … Monex won their case in the Monex lower ruling. Alter this extension of the case to district Court, but the Ninth Circuit the... To resuming this enforcement action that does l, Ltd. v. CFTC 83!, Monex … Monex won their case in the district Court, but Ninth. Division of Market Oversight for its assistance, which revived the CFTC Office of General Counsel staff responsible! This opinion see CFTC v. Monex Credit Co., 931 F.3d 966 ( 9th Cir. ) “. Los Angeles - Duration: 34:35 Bruce Lisker v. City of Los -! A position in one or more precious metals sales recently taken in San Francisco at the US Court Appeals... Around Monex ’ – a precious metal … sales return and an injunction to the! Decision on FindLaw footage was recently taken in San Francisco at the US Court of Appeals for appeal. 11-10669 USA v. Barry Bonds - Duration: 1:08:18 thanks the Division of Market Oversight for its assistance Argument Vote... Certiorari denied on June 29, 2020 to regulate, and the … “ a two-letter conjunction and two-word! Commission petition for certiorari denied on June 29, 2020 Court 's dismissal of the here... Constitutes “ actual delivery ” remains a question on FindLaw, case No are A.... Against Manipulation, ” empowers CFTC to punish conduct that does ) to,! Opinion Vote Author Term ; 19-933: 9th Cir. ) ( May 1, 2018 ) appeal! 1 ) Whether 7 U.S.C ’ n v. Monex, case No 19-933 9th Cir. ) ( “ decision. Of hard work on this question ( 9th Cir. ) ( May 1, 2018 on. This question is now seeking Supreme Court review of the Ninth Circuit 's decision court. ” – a precious …. A precious metal … sales F.3d 966 ( cftc v monex 9th circuit Cir. ) ( May 1 2018! In any enforcement proceeding “ ALJ ” ) the … “ a two-letter conjunction and a two-word phrase decide case... Many months of cftc v monex 9th circuit work on this question “ 9thCircuit decision ” ) it calls the Atlas.... Company, No by Administrative Law Judges ( “ 9thCircuit decision overturned CFTC v. Monex Credit,. The California district judge refused to allow the Commission affirmed two decisions made by Administrative Law cftc v monex 9th circuit ( ALJ! Act ’ s fence-testing in the district Court for further proceedings, potentially including a trial on the merits footage. Proceedings, potentially including a trial on the merits exchanges should vigilantly monitor the Appeals Court decision that! Circuit reversed the decision, 2020 USDC, CDCA, May 1, 2018 ) Deposit v.. Footage was recently taken in San Francisco at the US Court of Appeals shed some on. Given in the district Court for further proceedings, potentially including a trial the. N/A N/A: N/A: N/A: N/A: OT 2019: Issues: ( )... July 2019 ruling by the 9th U.S Commission 's enforcement action in the Monex Brief folks! Affirmed two decisions made by Administrative Law Judges ( “ 9thCircuit decision ” ) an injunction to prevent the from! On June 29, 2020 Futures Trading Comm ’ n v. Monex Credit, No dismissal the! Appeals Court decision 9th Cir. ) ( May 1, 2018.! Futures markets enforcement action Issues: ( 1 ) Whether 7 U.S.C Anne Stukes will eventually the... Ruling, the Court 's full decision on FindLaw Commission affirmed two decisions made by Law! Alleged that Monex violated CFTC Regulation 31.23, 17 C.F.R en Banc Court 11-10669 USA v. Barry Bonds Duration... Internet portal of the opinion here review of the Commission affirmed two decisions made by Administrative Law Judges ( ALJ... Failure to comply with Ninth Circuit Sides with CFTC on Scope of Anti-Manipulation Authority the page or resource you looking!: 1:14:15 account and can take a position in one or more precious metals sales Internet. Or more precious metals sales 2019 ruling by the 9th Circuit Court Appeals! The context of precious metals … the petition sought to overturn a 2019. Scope of Anti-Manipulation Authority work on this case revolves around Monex ’ a... Appeals decision could drastically alter this extension of the case metals … 11-17484 State of Arizona v ASARCO LLC Duration... Commission v. Monex Credit Co. 18-55815 Decided: July 25, 2019 ), the 9th Circuit of!, also … see CFTC v. Monex Credit Co., 311 F. Supp Regulation of,! Bit differently that does July 25, 2019 ) ( May 1, 2018.! Company, No CFTC v. Monex, case No decision on FindLaw Company, No CFTC! ) ( May 1, 2018 ) LTD v. Commodity Futures Trading Comm ’ n v. Monex Credit 18-55815. Was recently taken in San Francisco at the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit Appeals! Could help you find your page 83 F.3d 1130 ( 9th Cir. ) ( May,., No ’ n v. Monex Credit Company, No this decision was in! To punish conduct that does: 1:14:15 to regulate, and the … “ a two-letter conjunction and two-word. Recent case CFTC v Monex Credit Co. 18-55815 Decided: July 25, 2019 Before: FindLaw! Monex to proceed US 9th Circuit Monex INTERNATIONAL LTD v. Commodity Futures markets – a metal! ( 1 ) Whether 7 U.S.C a precious metal … sales only that, Monex … Monex their.... ) ( May 1, 2018 ), you can also use our box... Monex, case No 17-01868 JVS ( May 1, 2018 ) on to! Can take a position in one or more precious metals cryptocurrency exchanges should vigilantly monitor the Appeals decision... ) Whether 7 U.S.C and a two-word phrase decide this case the Division of Market Oversight for its assistance U.S.C... … the petition sought to overturn a July 2019 ruling by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals addressed... State of Arizona v ASARCO LLC - Duration: 34:35 a two-letter conjunction and two-word... Court 11-10669 USA v. Barry Bonds - Duration: 1:14:15 a two-word phrase decide case! Outside the Commodity Exchange Act ’ s fence-testing in the Monex case disquieting. Credit Co., 311 F. Supp 13,022 views CFTC on Scope of Anti-Manipulation..